In 2020, African American homeowners Paul and Tenisha Tate-Austin had their home appraised at $995,000, far below expectations. Suspecting bias, they brought in another appraiser but had a White friend pose as the owner. This time, the home was valued at $1.5 million—nearly $500,000 higher.
The couple filed a discrimination lawsuit, exposing racial bias in the appraisal process. The case, known as the Marin City racial discrimination lawsuit, went viral and severely damaged the appraiser’s reputation. This story highlighted deep flaws in traditional property valuations and sparked industry-wide discussions on bias and fairness.
"Having to erase our identity to get a better appraisal was a wrenching experience," Tate-Austin, said in a statement following the settlement.
How biased can the traditional appraiser assessment get?
In the U.S. mortgage industry, racial discrimination has been a major factor contributing to appraisal bias.
Research shows that properties in predominantly minority areas are undervalued 74% more often compared to those in White neighborhoods.
Even in areas with moderate minority populations, homes are 43% more likely to be undervalued. These statistics are more than just numbers on a report—major lenders have faced the consequences, paying significant fines for loan approvals based on flawed appraisals.
For mortgage originators and appraisers, this isn’t another social issue—rather, it's a business risk that hits hard. Every year, mortgage originators lose millions in fines due to inaccurate loan decisions, which creates a huge financial loss and can damage the company's reputation. The following are some headlines that shook the mortgage originators back to reality.
In the News
Wells Fargo Agrees for a 50M Settlement
In 2016, Wells Fargo was fined $50 million for overcharging homeowners on property appraisals after mortgage defaults. The issue involved appraisers inflating fees for these valuations, resulting in borrowers being charged more than necessary. This practice not only led to financial penalties but also damaged trust in their mortgage system.
Chicago-based mortgage lender Townstone Financial over alleged racial discrimination, results in $105,000 Fines
The U.S. Consumer Financial Protection Bureau settled a lawsuit with Chicago-based mortgage lender Townstone Financial over alleged racial discrimination, resulting in a $105,000 fine paid to the victims' relief fund. Townstone did not admit or deny the allegations, settling due to the government's stronger legal position.
$54 million charged against hidden Junk Fees
Ocwen Financial Corporation agreed to a settlement potentially totalling up to $54 million to resolve allegations of charging hidden "junk fees" related to property valuation services. The lawsuit accused Ocwen of undisclosed markup fees, leading to financial losses for borrowers and legal repercussions for the company.
The U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) Takes Charge Against Redlining
The U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) and the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) accused Fairway of "redlining" predominantly Black neighborhoods in Birmingham, Alabama. Redlining involves denying credit or offering less favorable terms to residents in certain areas based on racial or ethnic composition. Fairway agreed to pay $8 million to support loan subsidies and invest an additional $1 million in community programs. Additionally, a $1.9 million civil penalty was imposed.
Get the Highest Accuracy in Property Appraisals
Whether you are an Appraisal Management Firm or a mortgage originator that runs in-house appraisals, it's important to make a well-informed loan decision. The industry leaders have already cracked the code to automate the appraisal process, and they do so with advanced image recognition automation.
What’s Image Recognition?
Image recognition involves identifying objects or features within an image or video. While it might sound simple, this technology has evolved far beyond its early capabilities. Today, image recognition can handle complex, non-standard images, such as those of housing properties, where there are no fixed templates. The unpredictability of these images adds complexity, yet advanced technology now ensures highly accurate results.
As a subset of computer vision, image recognition identifies and interprets objects, features, and patterns in images. It leverages deep learning models, particularly convolutional neural networks (CNNs), to analyze visual data and make data-driven decisions based on the content. This technology plays a crucial role in applications like facial recognition, autonomous vehicles, and medical imaging.
In real estate and mortgage assessments, image recognition is used to evaluate property conditions accurately. This helps lenders make well-informed loan decisions by providing reliable, objective property analysis.
Image Recognition and Intelligent Document Processing [IDP]
When image recognition is combined with Intelligent Document Processing (IDP), it becomes a powerful tool for evaluating property conditions independently. The process begins by classifying images from the appraiser's documents and analyzing them one by one. This approach saves underwriters, loan officers, and auditors significant time typically spent reviewing appraisal documents. Overall, it streamlines the appraisal document review process, helping teams complete their work more efficiently.
Infrrd Image Recognition Workflow for Property Conditions
- Inject - The appraisal documents, which are usually PDFs containing text and images, are uploaded.
- Custom Training: Inffrd Image Recognition IDP model is trained using matched agents with properties using recommendations based on the features of viewed & liked properties.
- Image Classification: The system automatically extracts the images from the appraiser forms and then identifies the property images and classifies the different rooms/elements within a property.
- Image Processing: The system auto-extracts the tags from the image to identify different elements within an image such as electric stove, fridge, Mixer grinder, etc.(kitchen)
- Property Condition Analysis: Based on the elements extracted from the images, the system dictates the final condition of each of the rooms and or custom analytics specified by the client.
- Reliable Confident Score: Custom adjust the confidence score to evaluate the quality of extraction and check if the property meets the required standards.
FAQs
A pre-fund QC checklist is helpful because it ensures that a mortgage loan meets all regulatory and internal requirements before funding. Catching errors, inconsistencies, or compliance issues early reduces the risk of loan defects, fraud, and potential legal problems. This proactive approach enhances loan quality, minimizes costly delays, and improves investor confidence.
A pre-fund QC checklist is a set of guidelines and criteria used to review and verify the accuracy, compliance, and completeness of a mortgage loan before funds are disbursed. It ensures that the loan meets regulatory requirements and internal standards, reducing the risk of errors and fraud.
Using AI for pre-fund QC audits offers the advantage of quickly verifying that loans meet all regulatory and internal guidelines without any errors. AI enhances accuracy, reduces the risk of errors or fraud, reduces the audit time by half, and streamlines the review process, ensuring compliance before disbursing funds.
Choose software that offers advanced automation technology for efficient audits, strong compliance features, customizable audit trails, and real-time reporting. Ensure it integrates well with your existing systems and offers scalability, reliable customer support, and positive user reviews.
Audit Quality Control (QC) is crucial for mortgage companies to ensure regulatory compliance, reduce risks, and maintain investor confidence. It helps identify and correct errors, fraud, or discrepancies, preventing legal issues and defaults. QC also boosts operational efficiency by uncovering inefficiencies and enhancing overall loan quality.
Mortgage review/audit QC software is a collective term for tools designed to automate and streamline the process of evaluating loans. It helps financial institutions assess the quality, compliance, and risk of loans by analyzing loan data, documents, and borrower information. This software ensures that loans meet regulatory standards, reduces the risk of errors, and speeds up the review process, making it more efficient and accurate.
.png)
